GLEEwatch III: Return of the Gleek God this episode was the worst out of this season! The song selection? Ass! The drama? Self-indulgent! The main focus? William Schuester, the certified freak. Even the sideplots like Sus's date feel antithetical to the established character of the show and the conflict feels like something we got over five episodes ago. You know it's a bad episode when a Puck song is in the top three. And the Thong Song!!!!!!!! the lead up to that was like walking towards the plague I could feel it coming and I was screaming "Please No!" and it was torture. Barf! Lock Ryan Murphy up immediately! Song Ranking: 1. I Could Have Danced All Night (Emma) 2. Sweet Caroline (Puck) 3. Bust A Move (Schue) 4. Thong Song (Schue)