Too lazy for a fully articulated and well structured review today so you're getting this.
PROS
Firstly, it has an incredibly interesting concept and knack for worldbuilding. A narrative built throughout that shows great possibility, not just for reveals and such as the world keeps being built, but for explorations of interesting themes. Themes of humanity, in particular. This has a lot which it's setting up to hopefully talk about; I am picking the manga up for sure.
Secondly, it has possibly one of the greatest soundtracks I've heard, emotional when needed, otherworldly and creepy when needed, intense and exciting when needed, and always so beautifully layered and complex. I'm not knowledgeable in music theory to explain in any detail. I just think it's great.
Thirdly, it has some intriguing character development, which I won't spoil, and more is due in the manga without a doubt.
Fourthly, it has Some impactful body horror complemented by the world building. It's great stuff.
Finally, it has fantastic use of 3D camera work and the CGI aesthetic in battles. As well as this, it has noticeably strong layouts and a powerful aesthetic/ cinematographic identity overall. Not excluding what the CG allows in regards to visualising the gems.
CONS
The CGI is a great visual asset and more than justifies it's use, I wouldn't want it in another style, but it still leads to a couple very minor issues for me. Firstly, it doesn't always work great for comedy, often feeling like it has the voice acting and the base movement of what anime would usually offer in 2D, but without the full malleability that would have to exaggerate the comedy well. My opinion of course.
Secondly, there is this 3D rotating pan kind of camera movement they use, I don't know what the correct term for it is if there is one. Anyways, when it's used in otherwise still scenes and some character moments it feels very unecessary and gimicky to me. Like a Michael Bay scene where the camera has to move. It's distracting. I found it a tad obnoxious, but it did work at times, and its irritating uses were mostly isolated to episode one. Again, the 3D camera work was very good otherwise, particularly in action scenes.
Now after that massive nitpick. The con that actually matters to me and thus what score I want to give this (Should definitely be a 7.5, but for some reason I am being very generous and giving it an 8 because I am intrigued enough and expect the manga to deliver. Will see if I change my mind and rate it what I really should based on enjoyment), is that it just kind of ends.
The show has a cliffhanger, however, the ending is supremely awkward. While you could argue, and would probably be mostly right, that it's due to the adaptation length compared to the manga, only adapting the start, it nevertheless felt very, very awkward. It doesn't feel like a remotely natural ending. It's extremely abrupt and lacks almost any narrative structure. It doesn't feel like any arc had ended for example, or feel as if any big character moments were particular turning points compared to earlier sections with similarly noticeable changes, to justify ending there, and so forth. The way it cuts between the different pairs in the last few minutes added to this awkwardness, it just felt out of place. There was no reason to do that in the context of the narrative, other than the show thinking it should show you all the characters again quickly because it knows it's about to abruptly end.
...
Read more